"I’m The Great Pretender"
Isn’t there an unspoken something called a writer’s license where when you put a pen to paper (or a finger to a keyboard), even if it is a memoir, where is a certain allowance of stretching the facts? Since a memoir is a personal account of a personal story, what happens if the person writing it feels that certain occurrences will help further a point? Isn’t it a writer’s job essentially to entertain? If a story is juicier with some added features if only to satisfy the readers, should a writer be expelled from bookstores? Yes, James Frey wrote a memoir, A Million Little Pieces, and it sold lots of copies. He wrote about his dalliances with drugs and time spent in the slammer, and apparently there were some little white lies embedded within his truths.
Now I have never been one for little white lies. In fact, I think they can doom relationships and impeach presidents, but for the sake of writing…can little white lies be forgivable when the writer is not penning a personal letter but rather an experience for the masses (most of whom are strangers) to read?
James Frey is a man—he’s not President Bush (someone who we do demand the whole truth and nothing but the truth from). Frey is a writer, and that is what he did, he wrote a story about his life according to him. Even if he never spent a second behind bars, maybe he felt as if his addictions and self-loathing were like being imprisoned and to include a description as such would fail the point that he was trying to put forth.
I’ve never read Frey’s book. I tend to steer clear of anything on the Oprah book list (although I know she’s got great taste and if my own novel ever gets published and makes it to her favorites, I would be grinning from ear to ear). But still, great books have been pimped out on her show and she has done more for books and writers than…well…she’s done almost as much for books as the trees themselves. I’m not counting the books on tapes (or CDs) which I think should only be purchased by the blind.
But Oprah’s pathetic display of anger and even some welling of tears on her show while Frey sat there like a pig at a roast while the audience booed was unacceptable since only a couple of weeks before she phone in to the Larry King Show when Frey was a guest in support and to say that there was "much ado about nothing."
Frey may have told some tall tales about jail and not having Novocain at the dentist, but he cannot be deemed solely a liar. He is a writer. A writer who I read tried to first sell A Million Little Pieces as fiction, but who publishers were convinced was essentially a memoir. Frey maintains that the essence of his book is true.
Did you read his book and like it? Did you get a feel for his pain and suffering? Did it teach you something? Did you sympathize? Oprah sure thought so when she put it on her prized list. Millions thought so when they read it. Just because Frey fudged some words to make his story more enticing, does that mean the words imprinted on the page are no longer of any value?
Michael Moore did it with his films. And doesn’t Hollywood effin love him?
I wear makeup. Does that mean I lie to people everyday when I look them in the eye through my black mascara and eyelined lids because I used an enhancer to make my appearance more appealing?
Don’t we all expand a tale a bit to add some succulence to a story?
Don’t we often salt and pepper even our sweet mashed potatoes so they taste better?
What is truth when it comes to telling a story about a "common" man’s life?
I’ve heard that St. Martin's Press added a disclaimer to memoirist (and one of my favorite writers) Augusten Burroughs’ upcoming book. Would I care if I found out that Burroughs really didn’t have a much older boyfriend who said "he wished he could package my cum like ice cream so he could eat it all day"? No. I understand the point he was trying to convey by saying it.
I’ve said this before, and now again, all writing is full of half-truths and partial lies, even memoirs, if only for the lies we tell ourselves and believe every day. Memory is full of it too. How we all process memory is a unique transaction. The same thing can happen to two people and both parties could yield a difference experience. Like when my sister and I found film canisters in my parents’ room in a shoebox under the bed. She was maybe eight years old, which made me around eleven. We opened the gray-topped black plastic thing and found some sort of seeds in it. I had no idea what it was, but there were other things in the box that were far more interesting to us at the time—namely a cassette tape by The Platters featuring the song "The Great Pretender." My sister and I know every word to every song from that cassette.
Years and years later, she and I had a conversation about our find under the bed. After singing the lyrics "Oh yes, I’m the great pretender. Oooh, oooh, pretending that I’m doing well…" we touched on the film canister. "You know what that was?" she asked. "Yeah," I responded with some uncertainty. I’ve never smoked pot in my life so I really couldn’t be sure despite the fact that I’ve been in the presence of many people who have, parents included. We never fact-checked with them if it was pot or not. But it was.
In that very same conversation, my sister and I talked about the role we believed my dad played in a certain heist that earned headlines in the 80s, but then again, all this sleuthing was from two eavesdropping adolescents.
Do you believe me?
I do.
Did I entertain you?
Frey’s future career is said to be over.
There’s a million little pieces out there that I am going to pick up.
Now I have never been one for little white lies. In fact, I think they can doom relationships and impeach presidents, but for the sake of writing…can little white lies be forgivable when the writer is not penning a personal letter but rather an experience for the masses (most of whom are strangers) to read?
James Frey is a man—he’s not President Bush (someone who we do demand the whole truth and nothing but the truth from). Frey is a writer, and that is what he did, he wrote a story about his life according to him. Even if he never spent a second behind bars, maybe he felt as if his addictions and self-loathing were like being imprisoned and to include a description as such would fail the point that he was trying to put forth.
I’ve never read Frey’s book. I tend to steer clear of anything on the Oprah book list (although I know she’s got great taste and if my own novel ever gets published and makes it to her favorites, I would be grinning from ear to ear). But still, great books have been pimped out on her show and she has done more for books and writers than…well…she’s done almost as much for books as the trees themselves. I’m not counting the books on tapes (or CDs) which I think should only be purchased by the blind.
But Oprah’s pathetic display of anger and even some welling of tears on her show while Frey sat there like a pig at a roast while the audience booed was unacceptable since only a couple of weeks before she phone in to the Larry King Show when Frey was a guest in support and to say that there was "much ado about nothing."
Frey may have told some tall tales about jail and not having Novocain at the dentist, but he cannot be deemed solely a liar. He is a writer. A writer who I read tried to first sell A Million Little Pieces as fiction, but who publishers were convinced was essentially a memoir. Frey maintains that the essence of his book is true.
Did you read his book and like it? Did you get a feel for his pain and suffering? Did it teach you something? Did you sympathize? Oprah sure thought so when she put it on her prized list. Millions thought so when they read it. Just because Frey fudged some words to make his story more enticing, does that mean the words imprinted on the page are no longer of any value?
Michael Moore did it with his films. And doesn’t Hollywood effin love him?
I wear makeup. Does that mean I lie to people everyday when I look them in the eye through my black mascara and eyelined lids because I used an enhancer to make my appearance more appealing?
Don’t we all expand a tale a bit to add some succulence to a story?
Don’t we often salt and pepper even our sweet mashed potatoes so they taste better?
What is truth when it comes to telling a story about a "common" man’s life?
I’ve heard that St. Martin's Press added a disclaimer to memoirist (and one of my favorite writers) Augusten Burroughs’ upcoming book. Would I care if I found out that Burroughs really didn’t have a much older boyfriend who said "he wished he could package my cum like ice cream so he could eat it all day"? No. I understand the point he was trying to convey by saying it.
I’ve said this before, and now again, all writing is full of half-truths and partial lies, even memoirs, if only for the lies we tell ourselves and believe every day. Memory is full of it too. How we all process memory is a unique transaction. The same thing can happen to two people and both parties could yield a difference experience. Like when my sister and I found film canisters in my parents’ room in a shoebox under the bed. She was maybe eight years old, which made me around eleven. We opened the gray-topped black plastic thing and found some sort of seeds in it. I had no idea what it was, but there were other things in the box that were far more interesting to us at the time—namely a cassette tape by The Platters featuring the song "The Great Pretender." My sister and I know every word to every song from that cassette.
Years and years later, she and I had a conversation about our find under the bed. After singing the lyrics "Oh yes, I’m the great pretender. Oooh, oooh, pretending that I’m doing well…" we touched on the film canister. "You know what that was?" she asked. "Yeah," I responded with some uncertainty. I’ve never smoked pot in my life so I really couldn’t be sure despite the fact that I’ve been in the presence of many people who have, parents included. We never fact-checked with them if it was pot or not. But it was.
In that very same conversation, my sister and I talked about the role we believed my dad played in a certain heist that earned headlines in the 80s, but then again, all this sleuthing was from two eavesdropping adolescents.
Do you believe me?
I do.
Did I entertain you?
Frey’s future career is said to be over.
There’s a million little pieces out there that I am going to pick up.